A dog will whine for a variety of reasons, and it can be problematic and bothersome. Whining is mainly caused by a certain need. This need is normally to get rid of stress, or it is also brought about by other reasons.

Dogtra YS500
Our top pick
SportDOG No Bark Collar
Very effective
MaKa Dog Barking Control
Water proof
Naturepets Collar
Small-Medium dogs

A lot of dog owners merely remedy the whole situation without even digging deep to the cause of the behavior. Seeking other kinds of remedies can get rid of the whining, but then your canine might resort to other replacement behaviors like chewing the furniture around the house peeing just to seek your focus.

There are some factors you need to learn about before purchasing a standard bark collar because several types of this device might not work for a whining, baying dog.

Buying a device and simply putting it on your dog is not that simple; how it works on your dog will always have an impact on its success.

Citronella spray

The citronella spray collar is often activated using sound. However, some dog owners and veterinarians do not recommend the unit because they are often set off because of other sounds not relating to the dog barking, but they can be a good method to try on a howling or whining dog. This collar is what we personally recommend.

The volume of the dog’s howling/whining noise is placed at a degree to set off the microphone’s setting sensitivity. Others might think that the volume may not be sufficiently loud for the mike to respond to, but in that case, they perhaps do not have that big of a dog whining problem.


The majority of electronic bark collars are set off by a vibration sensor coming from the dog’s vocal cords whenever they bark. However, whining, growling, or howling sounds do not always create a sufficient amount of movement from the vocal cords to set the collar off.

This reaction is reasonable, since dog owners would run the risk of activating the collars unbecomingly if the collar’s degrees of sensitivity were reduced.

In addition, electric collars are controversial and are considered as the least humane approach in controlling unnecessary canine noise.


Collars of this kind include a tiny box with an electronic gadget that operates using a battery. (This one is our top pick) This box has a noise sensor that perceives the bark of a dog and gives off a high-frequency sound that is unnoticeable to human ears but loud enough for a dog to hear.

One of the benefits of this type of collar is it can offer a range of training options as compared with other bark collar types. It is also more humane compared to electrical shock collars, and the whole practice can be done discreetly as well.

However, the noise that the device emits might be too loud and annoying for the dog. Since we cannot hear the sound, we might not be aware of its effects on the dog.

Also, it might take in other sounds from the dog’s surroundings, thus this method is not ideal to use if you have other dogs around.

The Best Solution?

When it comes to whining and howling dogs, a common citronella bark collar will suffice. It is sound-activated, and it is typically affordable. If the whining or howling of your pet dog is loud, the device might prove to be a successful method.

The citronella collar works the way a standard collar would, but it has its distinctions. The device carries a tiny container filled with a harmless spray which has organic, diluted citronella oil.

The citronella bark collar includes an electronic mechanism which functions to perceive the dog’s barks. When the barking behavior happens for a preset period, and at a time that designates that incessant barking is ensuing, the electronic mechanism sets the citronella spray off, causing it to discharge a short spray of the diluted oil.

The dog will find this interruption as disagreeable to their problematic behavior, but will be unharmed during the process. If the behavior carries on, the collar will then again discharge another rush of the citronella oil.

The process will be a bit of a trial and error, but if you want more information about collars and remedies for such behavior, you can always seek the help of an animal behavior specialist.